“Substitution of Ideas” as a Dance to Struggle

“Substitution of Ideas” as a Dance to Struggle

Having annexed Crimea, Putin thought it’s going to be merely as easy to invade Donbas, where he used to be hoping to be supported by the use of pro-Russian Ukrainians throughout the house. Explicit military detachments led by the use of occupation officers of the secret services and products and merchandise were deployed by the use of him to Donbas. Georgia, Crimea, Donbas The Woman in Kherson – three times a enchantment.

One such officer was Lieutenant Colonel Igor Girkin (recognized underneath his alias as “Strelkov”) of Russia’s military intelligence, GRU, who had prior to now been eager about secret combat operations in Bosnia and Herzegovina, Transnistria, and a number of other hotspots. Girkin was appointed as chief saboteur and the commander in chief of the troops stationed throughout the breakaway republics in jap Ukraine. His process was to recruit as many local electorate as possible into the ones so-called “people’s armies.” Hiding its army underneath the quilt of this false banner, Russia began its military interference in this part of Ukraine, even though the Kremlin categorically denied this chain of command when challenged.

Propped up by the use of the ones covert Russian military units and at the instigation of FSB agents, officials in fairly a large number of areas in Luhansk and Donetsk spaces proclaimed themselves to be the government of “people’s republics.” A an an identical check out by the use of the Russian explicit services and products and merchandise to assert the formation of a “Kharkiv Other people’s Republic” was unsuccessful, alternatively. Kharkiv’s population resisted the proclamation of a quasi-republic, and officials of Kharkiv defied the encroachment of Russian authority on their the town. This defiance was now not forgotten. Putin was to take barbaric revenge after the start of hostilities of February 24, 2022, subjecting Kharkiv’s civilian population to punishing rocket and artillery shelling.

Having captured the town of Sloviansk in north Donetsk, Russian units led by the use of Girkin came upon themselves surrounded by the use of Ukrainian troops who outnumbered them. With the intention to quilt themselves, the Russian troops used a human shield of Sloviansk electorate, as Girkin himself later admitted. This was now not an isolated incidence. It was Russian protection handed down by the use of the President. Putin himself discussed the following in connection with the occupation of Crimea: “Let anyone from a variety of the [Ukrainian] military try to shoot at their own people, behind whom we will be standing. Now not in front, on the other hand behind. Let them try to shoot women and children.” It was Putin himself who urged Russian troops and pro-Russian separatists to use Ukrainian civilians as human shields.

Ukrainian troops overwhelmingly outnumbered Russian troops and equipment by the use of the beginning of July 2014. Curiously, alternatively, their commanders allowed Girkin’s Russian military saboteurs to withdraw from Sloviansk, and to fall once more and invade regional capital Donetsk throughout the south, which the Russian forces occupied as a substitute. Those who were part of the “Anti-Terrorist Operation” (ATO), the name the Ukrainian government gave to resisting Russia, claimed that they on no account received orders to obliterate the Russian troops that withdrew from Sloviansk and moved into Donetsk, even though the Russians used vehicles that that they had seized from Ukrainians. Given their strategic superiority, Ukraine’s air and flooring forces can have wiped out Girkin’s troops and that might perhaps were the highest of the “liberation” of Donbas by the use of Putin. Whether or not or now not this was stupidity or betrayal remains an unexplained mystery to in this day and age. However there were many such instances right through the Russian infiltration of Donbas – the sector of Luhansk and Donetsk.

In Kyiv, the country’s major politicians were divided among themselves and would perhaps each were now not in a position or unwilling to fight the annexation of Crimea and Russia in Donbas – perhaps fearing the personal consequences of such alternatives. Showing President Oleksandr Turchynov, Speaker of the Verkhovna Rada, was prompt to appoint Elementary Vitaliy Radetsky as Coverage Minister, a post he had held from 1993-1994 underneath President Kravchuk. His candidacy was supported by the use of the Head of the SBU, Ihor Smeshko. Turchynov was no stranger to the contradictory currents in Ukraine’s national government; he had been the principle civilian to transport the SBU underneath Yushchenko.

However, the Showing President stuck to the coalition agreement which stipulated that the Ministry of Coverage belonged to the nationalist Freedom Party, which, for its phase, nominated its party member Admiral Ihor Tenyukh. Tenyukh claimed that he pleaded a variety of events with Turchynov to allow him to begin out combatting the Russians in Crimea, on the other hand was time and again turned into down. He served from February 27 to March 25, 2014. and then resigned days after the annexation of Crimea, pointing out that he would possibly simply now not perform the duties entrusted to him. He was moreover scared of being made politically answerable for the loss of Crimea on the one hand and the desultory military response on the other.

Such was the political toxicity of the post that the country’s political control didn’t find a heavy-weight coverage minister between March and October 2014. Elementary Mykhailo Koval, prior to now Deputy Commander of Ukraine’s border regulate, held the post from March 25 to July 3. Valery Heletey was appointed from July 3 to October 14. He was a policeman along with the former head of protection of the newly elected President Petro Poroshenko. All through his temporary tenure, he received the rank of Colonel Elementary and solemnly swore in front of Rada deputies that the next Ukrainian victory parade may well be held in Sevastopol.

After all, as the country’s need {{of professional}} military control grew, a senior an expert after all licensed the duty. Elementary Stepan Poltorak, who had prior to now headed the Internal Ministry’s National Guard, managed to final 5 years as minister from October 14, 2014, to August 28, 2019, when the newly-elected President Vladimir Zelensky relieved him from his post.

The revolving-door appointment of coverage ministers and their modest professional caliber didn’t help to boost morale a variety of the Ukrainian military. In 2014, the Ukrainian army itself would possibly simply infrequently be known as an exemplary energy in spite of everything. It was half-armed and half-trained after twenty 5 years of peace following the collapse of the USSR and extra weakened by the use of Yanukovych’s military reforms. Its good fortune in Donbas was in line with the heroism of explicit individual Ukrainian army units, which ceaselessly acted in isolation, without coordination from central military command, and, in truth, on the heroism of the volunteer battalions, which bore the brunt of the conflict in Donbas. To thank as neatly were the efforts of private Ukrainians themselves, who sacrificed their personal monetary financial savings to pay for bringing the army once more to fighting scenario.

Ukraine’s political elite had all the time been further acutely mindful than every other nation that Vladimir Putin had been traumatized by the use of the collapse of the USSR, as he himself had time and again discussed. That underneath him the strategic function of the Russian Federation was the restoration of the Russian Empire. That his idea was ideologically draped spherical the concept that that of a Russian international where all Russian speaking people are united inside of a single state, as a substitute of Soviet Communism uniting the sphere. That Putin on no account noticed Ukraine as a territory deserving its private statehood or Ukrainian people as an established nation.

On the other hand, Kyiv had been caught off guard by the use of familiarity. This was now not completely surprising. After EuroMaidan, the Ukrainian oligarchs – or in order that they thought – would, as quicker than, re-arrange themselves spherical whomever was the new President to fight for a larger proportion of Ukraine’s financial gadget via Ukraine’s ritual abuse of state power. Putin would restart the tug of conflict with the new President to kick the Association Agreement another time into the long grass. The entire thing may well be different on the other hand the identical. Besides a defensive militarily build-up in jap Ukraine aimed toward Russia would possibly simply in a similar way provoke Putin – on whom Ukraine relied for fuel supplies – as Ukraine’s Russian-speaking officials and media throughout the house which might perhaps realize it as an check out at intimidation. Nor did Putin have a standing border army poised to suppress Ukraine.

They overpassed that the loss of Yanukovych as Putin’s President had created an another. After all, Putin had the “Georgian” selection available in Ukraine, as a result of the seething civil unrest. He would possibly simply exploit it to occupy border spaces where the secret services and products and merchandise had their maximum robust foothold: Crimea (where Russia even had troops to be had at its Crimean military bases), Luhansk and Donetsk. With minimum effort, the ones spaces may well be occupied as “independent” territories as Ukraine’s central government was paralyzed by the use of chaos and oligarchs carried out every other off in opposition to 1 another in a type of monetary musical chairs. It was in Russia’s passion now to fan the flames.

And that’s what happened. When incumbent President Yanukovych signalled he would surrender power to the opposition, Russian explicit services and products and merchandise, supported by the use of their agents in Kyiv, instigated first the taking photos of peaceful protesters, then the evacuation of Yanukovych by way of Crimea to Russia. This had the added benefit that throughout Russian exile Putin would possibly simply energy Yanukovych to finance Russia’s secret-service operations in Donbas from the billions the ex-burglar had gathered right through his Presidency. We established that that’s what happened with Yanukovych via two separate property of Michael Stanchev, co-author of this e book.

Irrespective of the facility vacuum in Kyiv one thing happened. The risk of the Russian invasion and subversive means of the Russian operatives and troops within Ukraine made it impossible to don’t anything else for long. On March 17, whole mobilization of the army was order for the principle time in recent history. Did Russia foresee this, or, within the tournament that they did, bargain it as irrelevant? They’re going to need to have. It intended that Ukraine’s whole military capability, such as it was, become a imagine Putin’s switch to grasp border spaces underneath the quilt of separatism.

By way of this time “separatists” had seized fairly a large number of government constructions in Donetsk and Luhansk spaces, along with the cities of Sloviansk, Lyman, Yenakijeve, Mariupol, Horlivka, and a variety of different others in order to get ready “legitimate” referendums. Unsuccessful makes an try to snatch government constructions and hoist the Russian flags were moreover made in Kharkiv, Dnipropetrovsk, and Zaporizhzhia. The war of words between supporters and fighters of the referendum on secession in Odessa on Would perhaps 2, 2014 led to a fire that killed dozens of people (in 2022 the investigation into the tragedy was nevertheless ongoing).

The Donetsk and Luhansk Other people’s Republics (“DPR” and “LPR”) proclaimed their independence on April 7 and April 28, amid mass unrest from the local population on the other hand with the direct beef up from the Russia Federation. Tellingly, Abkhazia and South Ossetia, the “self maintaining republics” occupied by the use of Russian forces invading the ones prior to now Georgian territories in August of 2008, were really useful to recognize their Ukrainian equals. No one throughout the international community recognized them, except for Lukashenko’s Belarus, al-Assad’s Syria, and other dictators in Nicaragua, Sudan and Central Africa Republic). In Ukraine, the DPR and LPR were known as “so-called republics,” which held “so-called referendums”, when on Would perhaps 11 the nominal leaders of the ones mini-states offered what they claimed were the counts of local plebiscites in want of secession from Ukraine.

On Would perhaps 25, 2014, Ukraine’s snap Presidential Elections were won by the use of Petro Poroshenko, the one-time rival of Tymoshenko’s underneath the Presidency of Yushchenko. He won 54 % throughout the first round against Tymoshenko’s 13 % as runner up. Poroshenko’s number one election promise was that he would end the stand-off with Russia inside of two to a couple of weeks of taking place of job. He had given voice to the hopes of Ukrainians at extensive that the political and army war of words would briefly end, bringing to an end the civil unrest.

The very next day, on Would perhaps 26, Ukraine underneath its new commander in chief, offered its greatest “Anti-Terrorist Operation” (ATO) against Russian forces on Ukraine’s territory, the use of airpower and paratroopers. Ukrainian troops forces retook Donetsk Airport, which was held by the use of its opponents, nicknamed “cyborgs” for their resilience, for 240 days.

On June 20, dressed in out his election promise in part, Poroshenko did announce a unilateral cease-fire on the part of the Ukrainian army, even though there was no precise cease-fire, for the reason that “separatists” continued baiting Kyiv with continued shelling, causing casualties among Ukrainian soldiers and civilians. Poroshenko’s solution lasted no more than 10 days. The unilateral ceasefire from the Ukrainian side resulted in blended reactions a variety of the Ukrainian military and politicians, so on July 1 the ATO-war resumed and two days later Poroshenko appointed his former body guard as Coverage Minister. The oligarchy in all probability had a formidable hand throughout the resumption of the ATO-war against Russia. Really extensive holdings of Rinat Akhmetov’s were in Donbas and, as his firms were now throughout the DPR and LPR, a singular kleptocracy threatened them – the Russian one somewhat than the Yanukovych family. By way of 2022, he was price a “mere” $4 billion, having out of place as much as 80 % of his web price.

On July 2, Ukrainian troops entered Luhansk, on the other hand were harassed to depart the town as early as July 6. However, on July 5, Sloviansk, Kramatorsk, and Artemivsk (since rechristened Bakhmut) were liberated from Russia’s forces “protective” the “separatists”.

Throughout July and August 2014, there were fierce battles, with more than a few ranges of good fortune. Cities changed hands. In August, the Russian Federation changed techniques and balled its forces proper right into a fist on the subject of Luhansk deploying a variety of battalion-tactical groups of the 76th Pskov Airborne Assault Division’s airborne regiments, along with the 61st Marine Brigade, with the beef up of tanks, which gave them the upper hand.

On August 29, a variety of Ukrainian volunteer units entered Ilovaisk, south of the town of Donetsk, on the other hand met stubborn resistance from Russian-backed forces. When the fighting become common, Russian troops intervened immediately and, for the reason that Ukrainian soldiers attempted to withdraw from Ilovaisk, that they had been surrounded by the use of the Russian army. It turn out to be the Ukrainian army’s greatest defeat for the reason that get began of the ATO-war. One and a half of of thousand troops were encircled.

Having after all won a decisive military victory, Russia mobilised a large-scale invasion energy of ordinary Russian army into jap Ukraine, which allowed them to snatch fairly a large number of districts throughout the Donetsk house without local opposition and switch on the subject of harbor the town Mariupol.

The Minsk Agreements

The defeat become the principle the reason why for the signing of the principle Minsk Agreements in a ringing ancient echo of Imperial Russia. Meeting on now not very independent territory in Minsk, Belarus, Ukraine was represented by the use of former President Kuchma (who had now not yielded in 1999 to KGB plant Elementary Marchuk), Russia by the use of its Ambassador to Ukraine, and, on the LPR and DPR side, by the use of their titular heads Igor Plotnitsky and Alexander Zakharchenko.208 A cease-fire was agreed on September 5, 2014. Consistent with its protocol, occasions agreed to stop hostilities on the an identical day, along with to monitoring and verification of the non-use of weapons by the use of the OSCE, who acted as independent observer to the negotiations.

Russia stipulated that Ukraine pass a law “On Transient Order of Local Self-Executive in Certain Areas of Donetsk and Luhansk Spaces” (ORDLO) which devolved power to these areas. The Verkhovna Rada passed it on September 16, 2014. Ukrainian govt bear in mind to lift elections in Donbas on December 7. The law presented a special procedure for local self-governance throughout the occupied areas of Donetsk and Luhansk spaces and avoided Ukrainian govt from prosecuting anyone who had taken joined its forces throughout the new “self maintaining” territories.

ORDLO’s wording on national language was moderately balanced. It gave every resident of Donbas the correct to make a decision what language they consider their native language: Ukrainian or Russian (or, technically, every other). However, Ukraine set preconditions: withdrawal of illegal armed units and army equipment from Ukraine; guarantees of freedom of expression of; independent remark of elections, along with representatives of worldwide organizations; non-interference throughout the electoral process; observance of the principles of political pluralism and freedom of political campaigning.

And so the Minsk Agreements on no account actually resulted in a ceasefire. The withdrawal of illegal Russian military on no account came about and the ceasefire was time and again violated by the use of each side. Ukraine for the reason that violated party was fascinated with adhering to the agreements in superb faith, on the other hand Russia, the aggressor, had no precise function of giving up its advertising marketing campaign of provocation. As quicker than, the global “separatists” stationed in Donbas frequently taunted the Ukrainian side, ultimate a unbroken provide of irritation with shelling and, when Ukraine spoke back, planted a seed a variety of the Donbas civilian population that Ukraine was in truth showing against them. The only clause throughout the agreement that was periodically performed was the prisoners’ business, even though this was on no account “excited about all” idea. Neither did the Minsk Agreements succeed in adopting a program for the economic revival of Donbas and the restoration of the realm’s business. Nor was there any dialogue about the future of Donbas.

None of this mattered to Russia. Putin’s precise function was to use his victory to suppress any discussion of Crimea underneath the agreements. In this he succeeded and as of 5 September, the Annexation of Crimea to the Russian Federation was a fait accompli via its exclusion from the forever spun-out talks in Minsk.

At a February 2015 summit, Germany and France joined the negotiations and a brand spanking new set of measures to put in force the Minsk Agreement were agreed in order to de-escalate the conflict. The ones bureaucracy were authorized by the use of a special UN resolution of February 17, 2015, which, even though advisory in nature, urged the occasions to put in force them (and implicitly sanctioned the status quo by the use of accepting the silence on Crimea).

Known as Minsk-2, it was once another time signed by the use of the three sides. As new problems, it built-in an immediate and whole ceasefire from 00.00. (Kyiv time) on February 15, 2015; the detailed withdrawal by the use of each side inside of 14 days of all heavy weapons to an an identical distance from the street of contact to create a 50 km wide protection zone; for artillery techniques of 100 mm caliber and above to create a 70 km wide protection zone; for a few unlock rocket techniques Tornado-S, Uragan, Smerch and tactical missile techniques Tochka (Tochka U), a 140 km wide zone. All this was to be monitored by the use of the OSCE mission the use of its relied on options.

Degree 4 of the agreement was the actual bone of competition: to begin a dialogue on the procedure for local elections in keeping with ORDLO and long run governance of the DPR and LPR. The Ukrainian side insisted on conserving the ones elections after the withdrawal of “global” (Russian) and other illegal military warring parties from the territory of Ukraine. Kyiv undertook duties to restore social and monetary members of the family with the territories occupied by the use of separatists, along with price of pensions and other expenses to the population of the ones areas, and resumed taxation there right through the jail framework of Ukraine.

Kyiv moreover insisted on the restoration of whole regulate of the state border of Ukraine right through the conflict zone by the use of the Ukrainian border guards. Border regulate was to begin on the first day after local elections in certain areas of the Donetsk and Luhansk spaces and end after a whole political settlement of the conflict by the use of the highest of 2015. Ukraine regarded as the “state border” to be the existing administrative Ukrainian-Russian border, that have been delimited and demarcated earlier, quicker than the occupation of Donbas, while the Russian side regarded as the street of contact throughout the conflict zone for the reason that state border. The Ukrainian side agreed to hold elections underneath ORDLO most effective after whole regulate was established over all the territory right through the former administrative hindrances, which the Russian side categorically didn’t comply with.

Russia wanted further concessions underneath its continuing aggression. The OSCE was now not given get entry to to the DPR and LPR so it could now not read about what was going down on the occupied territories after the agreement. Moreover Minsk-2 contained a paragraph that discussed: “the constitutional reform in Ukraine and the get admission to into energy by the use of the highest of 2015 of the new Constitution”, involving as a key section the decentralization of the state development of Ukraine, i.e., the actual acclaim for the autonomy of the DPR and LPR, and the passing into law of ORDLO.

If truth be told, engaging in constitutional reform and adopting a brand spanking new constitution was an inside matter of Ukraine. However, underneath energy of the defeat at Ilovaisk, President Poroshenko felt harassed to adapt to the inclusion of the ones problems into the second Minsk Agreement, now not working out that by the use of doing this he made all the set of agreements Minsk-2 unimplementable. Now Moscow had the correct to name for fulfillment of Minsk-2, signed by the use of Poroshenko, while accusing Ukraine of failing to comply with its duties underneath the agreements.

Poroshenko did understand totally neatly that behind all this was Russia’s attempt to interfere throughout the inside affairs of the Ukrainian state; Russia’s want to care for pro-Russian army underneath the guise of local militia; and Russia’s function to make a decision the appointment of prosecutors and judges loyal to the DPR, LPR and Russian govt, while maintaining Donbas at the expense of the Ukrainian taxpayer.

On 20 February 2015, the anniversary of the EuroMaidan heroes, Poroshenko made a bombshell claim right through a meeting with family of the dead. The background to his legitimate remark was that, on January 24, 2014, his predecessor Yanukovych had appointed a brand spanking new Chief of Body of workers, Andriy Klyuyev. As described above, in 2004 Klyuyev was an energy minister underneath Yanukovych as Prime Minister and captured on tape discussing the logistics of a covert operation that was a carbon copy of the second assassination check out on Orange Revolution leaders Viktor Yushchenko and Yulia Tymoshenko following the poisoning of the former. Klyuyev cherished a first-hand operating relationship with Vladislav Surkov, Putin’s Explicit Information on Ukraine along with Abkhazia and South Ossetia, the two spaces that had declared “breakaway independence” from Georgia after being occupied by the use of Russian forces. Surkov had arrived in Kyiv on 20 February 2014, the day of the mass killing of The Hundred civilians and officers.

At the commemoration, President Poroshenko discussed, “The control of the Protection Provider of Ukraine an expert me that [SBU anti-terrorist] Alpha opponents interrogated by the use of the corporate testified that Russian Presidential Aide Vladislav Surkov directed the gang of a host of global snipers on the Maidan.” There were moreover on-going phone conversations between Yanukovych and the Russian protection services and products and merchandise that the SBU had intercepted.

The Head of the SBU, Valentyn Nalyvaichenko confirmed the evidence that Putin’s Ukrainian stage man Surkov was behind the slaughter and that 3 groups of Russian secret-service agents had arrived in Kyiv from December 2013 to February 2014, ostensibly to show Ukrainian law enforcement on the dispersal of mass demonstrations. Nalyvaichenko identified his property, saying his SBU officers “gave us concrete knowledge [under interrogation] regarding the positions of global sniper groups that were focused on every protesters… and Internal Ministry police officers.”

A week later, on Russia’s state Channel One, Vladimir Putin for my part spoke back to the accusation. Pleading that the order would possibly simply now not have come from him, Putin known as it “whole, utter nonsense,” and that it was “up to now from fact that I have no idea where it’s going to come from.” He added, “I’d ask [others] to be further attentive when the use of wisdom purchased by the use of my Ukrainian colleagues”.

Instead, alternatively, of giving Ukraine beef up, the West and the US gave the impression the unsuitable approach as had happened with Georgia in 2008. Ukraine was being isolated in one of the vital the most important dear mistakes in global affairs made throughout the twentieth first century.

With the intention to appease Russia, the West and the US put energy on Ukraine, now not simple with Russia that Ukraine stick with the Minsk Agreements, even though working out that Russia, for its phase, had no function of doing so. This misguided and short-sighted protection would possibly simply now not lead to an end to violence, on the other hand most effective made further enlargement of Russia’s territory and escalation of violence a subject matter of time. In history, classes are discovered the laborious manner.

After the irritating enjoy of Crimea’s annexation and the ATO against covert Russian forces, underneath Petro Poroshenko very first steps were after all made to align Ukraine’s military with NATO necessities and bring the army underneath regulate of civil control. Poroshenko set this in motion alongside a huge (for Ukraine) investment to strengthen military equipment. President Zelensky developed this protection further by the use of working out Russia as a security possibility to Ukraine and refining interoperability with EU and NATO forces. Whether or not or now not it was enough, or too little too past due, lies throughout the stability after the invasion.

Having carried out the Georgian selection for Ukraine, Putin dropped his facade. The Kremlin now not known as Ukraine a brother nation while twisting arms behind the scenes to stop its leaders from turning into a member of NATO or embarking on a path against membership of the EU and extorting it otherwise. Having tried for a few years to regulate Ukraine’s Presidency behind the scenes, Putin had succeeded in fighting Ukraine from turning – like 1990s-run-down Poland had – into a formidable financial gadget of 40 million-people and a military gorilla on its doorstep. On the other hand he had failed in his number one function – this was Putin’s “Ukraine complicated” – and the gloves remained off.

Using round-the-clock propaganda channels that monopolize the Russian media, Putin’s government continued to shape an image of Ukraine in Russia as its enemy threatening the independence and protection of the Russian state. Ukrainians who were full of life throughout the Maidan were denigrated as “Banderites”. At the an identical time, Ukrainian leaders and army officers were depicted as Nazis to insinuate that that that they had won illegal regulate, and the new territories he wanted were referred to as Novorossiya. None of it made ancient sense, on the other hand that didn’t matter. By way of “substitution of ideas”, Putin created a tale that identified Russia for the reason that savior of the peaceful Russian-speaking people living in Ukraine who were being suppressed by the use of evil actors.

This now served for the reason that informational and ideological basis on which the Kremlin’s military methodology against Ukraine was built. Putin himself joined the unsuitable data conflict aimed toward Russians. In speeches and “ancient articles”209 he claimed that Russians and Ukrainians were “one people” with “one faith,” discounting the lifetime of Ukraine as a state an identical in independence and sovereignty. The most important section throughout the war of words between Russia and Ukraine were the economic, and trade wars between the two global places. To justify his aggression, Putin used the “acclaim for the jail status of Crimea” on the one hand and Ukraine’s cooperation with NATO on the other. The latter allegedly threatened Russia’s protection and the status of the Russian language in Ukraine.

Later, prior to the invasion of Donbas, those arguments were supplemented by the use of the “possibility from NATO” in case Ukraine was licensed into its ranks, arming the Ukrainian army and “strengthening Nazism” that “threatened the safety” and even the “territorial integrity” of the Russian Federation. That they had been all problems, in truth, which his annexation of Crimea and “separatist” advertising marketing campaign in Ukraine’s Donbas had intentionally accelerated. As he had already created a territorial dispute, there was no likelihood that NATO, a defensive alliance, would invite Ukraine as a member.

Over 8 years the Kremlin had poisoned Russian minds against Ukrainians suggesting that Ukraine’s Russian-speaking citizens cried out for a patriotic combat to save some them. On February 21, 2022, the best day on which Yanukovych “surrendered” (in line with Putin) his Presidency in 2014, and four days quicker than attacking Ukraine, Russia fired the start shot. Its Duma officially recognized the sovereignty of the Donetsk and Luhansk Other people’s Republics from Ukraine, ignoring forceful protests from Ukraine’s President Zelensky. This reputation came about against the backdrop of an strange center of attention of Russian troops along the Russian-Ukrainian and Belarusian-Ukrainian borders, and it become glaring that his army used in an effort to attack as we had predicted. The day after the “Defender of the Place of birth Day” reside efficiency at the Kremlin Palace, on February 24, 2022, Putin addressed the Russian people and offered the start of a “explicit military operation” against Ukraine and that it was already on its manner.

The post “Substitution of Ideas” as a Dance to Struggle gave the impression first on The Data.